Menu - New Paltz NY Restaurant (2024)

NACHOS Sm 9.95 Lg 12.95

Shredded Cheddar and Monterey Jack cheeses melted over tortilla chips and topped with guacamole, jalapeño peppers, sour cream, fresh tomatoes and black olives, served with salsa.
Add Chili 3.00 Add Grilled Chicken 5.00 Add Cajun Chicken 5.00

CHICKEN WINGS (12) 13.95

Regular, Hot, Parmesan Garlic, BBQ, Golden BBQ, or Teriyaki. Served with celery and blue cheese dressing.

CHEDDAR JALAPEÑO POPPERS (7) 7.95

Served with sour cream.

Bavarian Pretzel Sticks (4) 9.95

Served with cheddar lava sauce.

PARTY PLATTER 16.95

8 wings, 4 poppers and 4 mozzarella sticks.

MOZZARELLA STICKS (6) 7.95

Served with homemade marinara sauce.

HOMEMADE CRAB CAKES (3) 11.95

Served with coleslaw and Chesapeake sauce.

POTATO SKINS (6) 8.95

Potato skins topped with cheddar and Monterey Jack cheeses, bacon and sour cream.
Add Chili 3.00

FRIED CALAMARI 16.95

(Original or Buffalo)
A large portion served with homemade marinara sauce OR tossed in our Buffalo sauce and sprinkled with crumbled blue cheese.

Fried Brussel Sprouts 10.95

(Buffalo Style Too)
Served with chipotle aioli or blue cheese.

CHICKEN TENDERS (4) 10.95

(Original or Buffalo)
Choice of BBQ sauce or honey mustard.

QUESADILLAS

Garnished with salsa and sour cream.
Cheese 8.95 Chicken 10.95 Vegetable 10.95 Pulled Pork w/ Slaw 12.95 Chicken Bacon Ranch 12.95 Southwest: Cajun chicken, black beans and corn 12.95

CAESAR SALAD Sm 5.95 Lg 7.95

Served with toasted garlic bread.

TOSSED SALAD Sm 5.95 Lg 7.95

Fresh mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion and croutons.

P&G's ICEBERG WEDGE SALAD 11.95

Fresh cut wedge of iceberg lettuce topped with chopped bacon, tomatoes, scallions, blue cheese dressing and cracked black pepper.

SPINACH SALAD Sm 9.95 Lg 11.95

A large bowl of baby spinach topped with fresh mushrooms, tomato, bacon, hard boiled egg, feta cheese and sprouts.

COBB SALAD 13.95

Turkey, avocado, black olives, feta cheese, hard boiled egg, bacon, diced tomato, sprouts and croutons served over fresh mixed greens.

P&G's CHICKEN CHOPPED SALAD 15.95

Grilled chicken breast with fresh greens, tomato, cucumber, carrot, bacon and crumbled blue cheese served with balsamic vinaigrette.

P&G's VEGGIE CHOPPED SALAD 13.95

Avocado, fresh greens, tomato, cucumber, carrot, broccoli, craisins and walnuts served with balsamic vinaigrette.

FRESH SEAFOOD SALAD 16.95

Fresh scallops, shrimp and calamari served over a large bowl of mixed greens with provolone cheese, roasted red peppers, and mandarin oranges, tossed in a red wine vinaigrette.

FRESH KALE AND ROASTED BEET SALAD 13.95

A heaping bowl of baby kale tossed with roasted beets, baby spinach, carrots, crumbled goat cheese and walnuts in a red wine vinaigrette.

SOUTHWEST CHICKEN SALAD 15.95

Fresh greens topped with Cajun chicken, corn, black beans, avocado, tomato, red onion and jack cheddar cheese. Served with creamy avocado dressing.

ADD-ONS TO SALADS:

Chicken 6.00 • Salmon 9.00 • Fried Calamari 8.00 • Grilled Shrimp 8.00 • Steak 12.00

DRESSINGS:

Balsamic Vinaigrette • Blue Cheese • Creamy Garlic • Parmesan Peppercorn Ranch • Caesar • Russian • Italian • Honey Mustard • Creamy Avocado • Sesame

SOUP OF THE DAY Cup 4.50 Bowl 5.95

Check under SPECIALS.

Stormy's Famous Chili Cup 4.95 Bowl 6.50

Served with a buttered hard roll. Add Cheese $1 Add Sour Cream $1

Classic Crock of French Onion Soup 7.95

Smothered with mozzarella and Swiss cheese.

New England Clam Chowder Cup 4.95 Bowl 6.50

The white one.

MAKE IT A BREAD BOWL add 2.95

Pick Two 9.95

Select any two of the following: ½ Deli Favorite Sandwich* • Cup of Soup • Small Tossed Salad
French Onion Soup: Add 3.00 Iceberg Wedge Salad: Add 5.00

* - See DELI FAVORITE SANDWICHES in the SANDWICHES menu.

Cornerstone Classic Sandwiches:

Includes a side dish. Find a list of sandwich sides here.

Chicken BLT 14.95

Freshly breaded chicken cutlet, deep fried and topped with American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on a toasted club roll.

The P&G's Dip 14.95

Thin sliced roast beef w/ melted provolone cheese on a garlic club roll, served w/ dipping jus.

The P&G's Club Sandwich 12.95

Your choice of turkey, ham & cheese or roast beef w/ crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo.

Fresh Salmon Sandwich 15.95

A salmon fillet grilled plain or Cajun spiced and served on toasted garlic bread w/ lettuce and tomato.

Tommy I's Crab Cake Melt 15.95

Jumbo homemade crab cake with melted Swiss cheese, coleslaw and Chesapeake sauce on grilled rye bread.

Pastrami or Turkey Reuben 14.95

Pastrami or oven roasted turkey breast with sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread.

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich 12.95

A tender breast grilled plain, Cajun spiced or BBQ'd on a toasted kaiser roll w/ lettuce & tomato.

The George Wrapp 15.95

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, spinach, fire roasted tomatoes and pesto mayo in a flour tortilla.

Buffalo Chicken Wrap 13.95

Crispy chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce w/ lettuce, tomato & blue cheese in a flour tortilla.

Chicken Caesar Wrap 13.95

Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce and Caesar dressing in a flour tortilla.

Hot Open Steak 16.95

A Flat Iron steak charbroiled to your satisfaction, served on toast and topped with crispy fried onions.

Hot Open Roast Beef or Turkey 11.95

Heaps of freshly roasted beef or turkey topped with homemade gravy.

The Godmother 15.95

Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, spinach, fire roasted tomatoes and pesto mayo. Served on a toasted ciabatta roll.

Pulled Pork Sandwich 14.95

Dry rub, slow cooked pork shoulder on toasted Brioche roll w/ slaw. Served w/ BBQ sauce.

Deli Favorite Sandwiches:

Served with your choice of Macaroni Salad or Cole Slaw.
(Deli Favorites do not include a side dish.)

Grilled Cheese 7.95 • Grilled Ham & Cheese 8.95 • Honey Ham & Cheese 8.95 • Grilled Bacon & Cheese 8.95 • Fresh Roasted Turkey Breast 8.95 • Fresh Roasted Beef 8.95 • Pastrami 8.95 • Classic BLT 8.95

* See also: Pick Two in the SOUP & SALAD menu.

The Burger 14.95

8 oz. of freshly ground Angus beef charbroiled and served with your choice of topping on a toasted hard roll with lettuce and tomato.

The P&G's Burger 15.95

8 oz. of freshly ground Angus beef charbroiled and topped with melted Swiss cheese and mushroom gravy on a toasted hard roll.

The Cornerstone Burger 15.95

8 oz. of freshly ground Angus beef charbroiled and topped with melted muenster cheese, fried jalapeños and cracked black pepper mayo on a toasted brioche roll.

The Big Kid Burger 11.95

4 oz. of freshly ground Angus beef charbroiled and served with your choice of topping on a bun with lettuce and tomato.

Turkey Burger 14.95

Homemade fresh seasoned turkey burger with your choice of topping, lettuce and tomato on a toasted roll.

California Garden Burger 14.95

A vegetarian burger topped with guacamole, Swiss cheese and sprouts. Served on a toasted hard roll with lettuce and tomato.

The Mack Truck Burger Melt 15.95

8 oz. of freshly ground Angus beef charbroiled and topped with homemade macaroni and cheese, nestled in a grilled cheese sandwich.

Impossible Burger 15.95

An all natural plant based burger served with lettuce and tomato on a toasted hard roll.

Additional Toppings

$1.50 ea: American • Blue Cheese • Cheddar • Goat Cheese • Mozzarella • Muenster • Provolone • Swiss • Bacon • Mushrooms • Jalapeños
$2.00 ea: Chili • Avocado • Fresh Mozzarella • Guacamole • Fire Roasted Tomatoes • Crispy Fried Onions • Sautéed Onions • Fried Jalapeños

Burger and Cornerstone Classic Side Dishes

Burger and Cornerstone Classic Sandwich prices include a side dish. Choose from:

French Fries, Waffle Fries, Macaroni Salad, Cole Slaw, Side Salad, Baked Potato, Mashed Potatoes, Green Beans, Brocolli, Brussel Sprouts, Corn, Black Beans, Pasta, Rice of the Day.
Add $2.00: Onion Rings, Roasted Beets, Sweet Potato Fries, Eggplant Fries, Homemade Macaroni & Cheese. • Fried Green Beans • Cup of Soup

Golden & Crispy:

Golden & Crispy meals served with French Fries and Cole Slaw

Fried Chicken In A Basket 14.95

An old fashioned favorite.

Basket of Tenders (3) & Fries 11.95

Served with your choice of BBQ or honey mustard.

Crispy Chicken Cutlet Sandwich 13.95

Freshly breaded chicken cutlet, deep-fried and served on a hard roll with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. *Buffalo Style Too!

Guinness Battered Fish-n-Chips 14.95

Guinness battered cod, deep fried and served with tartar sauce.

Fried Clams 11.95

A large portion of deep-fried, breaded clam strips served w/ a lemon wedge & tartar sauce.

Fried Seafood Platter 14.95

Deep-fried cod, shrimp and clams served w/ tartar & co*cktail sauce and a wedge of lemon.

Fried Shrimp (8) 12.95

Deep-fried shrimp served with co*cktail sauce and a wedge of lemon.

A LA CARTE SIDES:

Dinner Selections — served all day

Served with fresh bread and your choice of a cup of soup or a tossed salad. French Onion Soup: add $3Iceberg Wedge Salad: add $5

Steak:

Served with your choice of two sides.

Flat Iron Steak 8 oz. 24.95

Bourbon Marinated Hanger Steak 10 oz. 29.95

NY Strip Steak 12 oz. 32.95

Enhancements —
Shrimp $6 • Scallops $9 • Bleu Cheese $2 • Sautéed Onions $2

Prime Rib (12 oz.) 24.95

P&G's Famous Prime Rib Special - Roasted in its own juices and served to your satisfaction.
Every Thursday & Saturday evening, starting at 4:00 PM.

Seafood:

Served with your choice of two sides.

Fresh Atlantic Salmon 24.95

Broiled, grilled, Cajun spiced or sesame glazed. With your choice of two sides.

Broiled Seafood Combo 26.95

Salmon, jumbo shrimp and sea scallops topped with a light lemon caper cream sauce. With your choice of two sides.

Shrimp Scampi 22.95

10 Jumbo shrimp sautéed in our own scampi butter. With your choice of two sides.

Chicken:

Served with your choice of two sides.

Chicken Francaise 24.95

A boneless breast of chicken, egg battered and sautéed in a lemon butter sauce.

Chicken Marsala 24.95

A boneless breast sautéed with fresh mushrooms in a Marsala wine sauce.

Chicken Parmigiana 24.95

A freshly breaded breast topped with our homemade marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.

Pasta:

Chicken & Shrimp Pesto Pasta 22.95

Tender chicken and jumbo shrimp sautéed in a creamy pesto sauce with fresh broccoli, mushrooms and roasted red peppers over linguine.

Seafood Fra Diavolo Pasta 24.95

Jumbo shrimp, sea scallops and calamari sautéed in a spicy marinara sauce. Served over linguine.

Penne a la Vodka 15.95

Penne pasta tossed in a creamy Romano sauce.
Add chicken: 6.00; Add shrimp: 8.00; Add salmon: 9.00; Add steak: 12.00

Eggplant Parmigiana 21.95

Freshly breaded eggplant layered with our homemade marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.

Vegetable Stir Fry 18.95

Fresh garden vegetables sautéed in a toasted sesame garlic sauce over pasta. Add chicken: 6.00; Add shrimp: 8.00; Add salmon: 9.00; Add steak: 12.00.

• Daily Specials
• Weekly Specials